Friday, January 22, 2016

Apple Praline Pie | A Baker Is Born

I'm no spring chicken . . . . it's taken me the best part of my cooking life to finally make a great pie, repeatedly.

This is despite the fact that my mother had a reputation as one great pie baker.  This is despite the fact that I (I think I) paid attention at her elbow. And despite the fact that I have tried many recipes, many times, and end up wanting to throw the rolling pin through the kitchen window.

It was last fall when I felt I'd mastered the pie crust I always wanted to make, thanks to this recipe. This is the vodka recipe, developed by J. Kenji Lopez-Alt, managing culinary director at Serious Eats. He developed the technique while working at America's Test Kitchen, though, so Chris Kimball gets all the credit :(

Still it's a great recipe ~ and it's even better when it envelops this pie.

My sister-in-law Liz gave me this recipe and she got it from a friend's mother.  No credit on the recipe card, but the closest thing I found to it on the Internet is this.

What I found different about this recipe -- and utterly delectable -- is the fact the it's a double-crusted pie, with the the praline topping on top of the second crust. Talk about gilding the lily!

So, if you have no fear of making your own pie crust, give this apple pie a try.  You can also use Pillsbury's crusts.  The friend's mother who shared this recipe quietly confessed that she used refrigerated crusts.  "Didn't used to," she says, "but they've gotten so much better and they're just as good."  Good in a pinch, but not when I can ~ now, anyhow ~ pack a couple disks of this dough in the freezer!

And if you want to learn more about picking just the right kind of apples, read my piece on the Kitchen Journals, a beautiful and informative website.

Praline Apple Pie
For the pie:
Pastry for two crust pie -- your favorite or mine
6 cups thinly sliced, peeled apples (I used Northern Spy)
3/4 cup sugar
1/4 cup flour
1 teaspoon cinnamon
1/4 reaspoon salt
2 tablespoons butter

Prepare your pie crust. Heat the oven to 350 degrees F. In a large bowl gently toss the apples with the flour, sugar, cinnamon and salt.  Spoon into pastry lined pan. Dot with small pieces of the butter. Top with second crust, and cut several slits for venting. Bake for 50 to 55 minutes or more, until the apples are tender and crust is golden.  Cover the edges of the crust if it starts to brown too much.  (My SIL advised me that her pie took at least an hour, maybe more. She warned me to "wait til it's bubbling through the slits some." Good advice.)

For the topping:
1/4 cup butter
1/2 cup firmly packed brown sugar
2 tablespoons half and half
1/2 cup chopped pecans*

In a small saucepan, melt the butter. Sir in the brown sugar and half and half. Slowly bring to a boil. Remove from the heat and stir in pecans. Spread over the top of the baked pie. Place pie on a baking sheet to catch any spills. Return the pie to the oven and bake 5 minutes more or until topping bubbles. Cool at least an hour before serving.

* Although I used pecans the first couple times I made this pie, you'll see walnuts in these pictures. Just a little cheating!


  1. Hi Rosemary, I agree with your friend's mother - shop-bought pie crusts have got a whole lot better although I think to do this pie justice, I'll make the crust. The pecan topping isn't gilding the lily, it is raising the apple pie's game! Pass me a fork please !

  2. It is a really good pie, Hester! I exercised great restraint and only had two pieces ~ the rest were Mr. Rosemary's. He likes his apple pie topped with ice cream or whipped cream. My dad? Cheddar cheese.

  3. I made an apple pie today---it's taken me years, too, to get the technique down. And often they aren't so great in the looks department. But they usually taste wonderful. I'm pinning your pie---it will be next on the list when I get another apple pie craving :)

    1. I'm sure you'll like it, Liz. You're right, this pie wouldn't win any beauty contests, but still a winner!

  4. This sounds wonderful! I am a nut for pecans :) so the topping sounds delightful to me. I haven't tried the vodka pie crust yet but will next time I bake a pie.

    1. I love pecans, too, Susan; I confess I often sub walnuts because they're a bit cheaper, but pecans are best here! And do try the crust -- hard to believe vodka makes the difference, but I've seen (and tried) recipes with vinegar that also promise a tender, flaky crust.

  5. I've always let my sister do the apple pie baking too. But we have never enjoyed one with a double crust and praline topping on top! That's just over the top and screaming to be made! Thanks Rosemary! Pinned and saved!

    1. I wish I would got the pie gene from my mother, . . . . but none of my sisters or brothers did! Wonder why. Glad, that after some practice and trial and error, Roz, I think I got it!

  6. I think a great crust, and a great apple pie, are the ultimate tests of a great cook, I can't wait to try these Rosemary!

    1. As soon as I can make the crust without looking at the recipe a zillion times, THEN I'll allow myself "great" status as a pie baker. The crust is worth a try, Sue. Thanks for stopping by.

  7. Chris Kimball always seems to hog a lot of credit, doesn't it? I love the recipes that come from his magazine (more the thinking process that gets to the final result, actually), but it always interests me how many really good cooks have worked for him. And moved on. Anyway, this is such a great recipe! I can bake, but don't like to. Fortunately Mrs KR does -- so I'll make sure she sees this! Thanks so much.

    1. I love the science of how to make things better/right as much as enjoying the final result, too, John. I do enjoy America Test Kitchen stuff, though. Must be a helluva training ground!

  8. This pie just warms up my winter soul. I have a love-hate relationship with pie crust. Even when it turns out great the first time, it doesn't the second time. This makes wonderful use of our Minnesota apples!


I realize you don't have to take the time to comment . . . but it makes my day! So glad you decided to stay.